Shang Chi

Sep. 4th, 2021 11:15 pm
potofsoup: (Default)
I just watched Shang Chi! (it's only out in theaters and not online, which... I'm not sure what Disney is trying to do. But I'm trying to support motives with Asian American main characters so... I bought a ticket and hied myself hence, to the first movie I've seen in the theaters since Endgame! Or maybe Nezha.) Anyways, I sat in a seat that was at least 10 feet from everyone else and wore a mask the entire time, so I think I was pretty safe.

Overall, I liked it! I'd put it amongst one of the better Marvels.

1) The fight scenes were actually good! Creative settings, well-paced, each one was different, and the camera work followed the action properly instead of jittering all over the place.

2) I really liked the language fluidity of the movie, shifting from Chinese to English and back again. Most people in the movie were bilingual and it works really well, having them shift from Chinese-only spaces to English spaces, to the mixes in between. There's scenes where they basically start speaking Chinese, and Awkwafina's like "oh hey" and everyone just shifts smoothly into English. I do wish the climatic moments were in Chinese, especially when it's just between Shang Chi and his family, but you can't get everything. (Also, it's weird that everyone in Macau speaks Mandarin, but Disney's obviously trying to sell to mainland audience, and at least unlike Pacific Rim people actually speak Chinese)

3) As with most Marvel movies, the plot isn't particularly amazing, but it's serviceable, and doesn't have any "wtf?" moments like Endgame or Civil War. The bits of backstory reveal also worked quite well. I also really liked the humor in the movie -- it didn't really take away from the drama of the moment as it sometimes does in other Marvel films.

4) Oh I really liked the mythical creature cameos! It was cool to see Qilin and 9-tailed foxes and a proper Chinese dragon that fought with water.

Overall it was nice to see a movie where China and Chinese Things did not feel exotified. Marvel, as usual, cannot follow through a theme to save their life, but it was a solid movie, and it's exciting to see characters added to the Marvel Club that are clearly Chinese American in identity.

Okay, next are some more spoilered comments

spoilers )
potofsoup: (Default)
Well, I've been back in person since Aug 11, but school officially started with students on campus on Aug 23, so it's been 2 weeks of teaching full classes with everyone masked but not distanced. At least our campus is 98% vaccinated, which is good. The bad news is that we still had a few students test positive, which lead to quite a lot of anxiety and furor. The students who tested positive were asked to stay home and not return until confirming a negative COVID test, but the entire campus of ~500 people are considered "close contacts" because between 8 classes and no distancing rules, it was easier than doing contact tracing. And the guidance has been that vaccinated close contacts merely have to self-monitor. This has, naturally, made people who have unvaccinated children at home super nervous.

some rambling about testing )
potofsoup: (Default)
I saw this floating around recently and greatly enjoyed reading others' responses, so here's mine. Adjusted the language to be less fic-centric,



1) How many works do you have on AO3?
178! Of which... 99 works are either comics, art, or PDFs of fanbooks that I made, and 25 are collabs where I was just providing the art and someone else was doing the words. So that means the actual number of fics is 54.

2) What’s your total AO3 word count?
660,074 words listed in the stats - 363,535 words written by other people in the collabs = 296,539 words. This comes out to 5.5k words per fic, which sounds about right.

3) How many fandoms have you written created for and what are they?
99% Captain America, with 3 Witcher fics and 1 Untamed fic. I am... predictable.

long )
potofsoup: (Default)
Well, I restarted Firefox and it insisted on reasserting the horrible Proton tab look on me, which... no. I want spacer lines between my tabs. When they pushed the new version in June, it was a pretty simple setting to undo in about:config, but this time it's a multi-step process. ::shakes fist at firefox::

Anyway, here's how you fix your tabs, in case anyone is still on Firefox: https://winaero.com/disable-proton-in-firefox-91/
potofsoup: (Default)
You know what I miss from the last time I was on LJ back in 2005? People commenting on webcomics feeds. It really felt like I was reading a comic with a community, to be able to click on comments and see other people's reactions. I feel like it's different from commenting on the comic's website itself -- feels more intimate, somehow. Anyway I haven't seen that happen so much here, and I'm wondering if that's just not a thing that people do anymore, or whether I'm just not following the right webcomics.

Anyway, here are the ones that I follow:
[syndicated profile] xkcd_feed
[syndicated profile] smbc_comics_feed
[syndicated profile] dinosaur_comics_feed
[syndicated profile] catandgirl_feed

And I'm just going to start commenting on them, bc why not.

Are there other webcomics that I should be following here on DW? Or have people moved away from that practice?
potofsoup: (Default)
COVID:
Oh man, some of the latest data on COVID is ... not great -- that study from Israel of Long COVID that says 20% of the vaccinated people who got COVID ended up with Long COVID, egh. (Although the study did point out that it means 0.5% of those who were vaccinated got Long COVID, which sounds slightly less worrying.) Long COVID sounds absolutely dreadful. Also, just read about the Massachusetts outbreak, which confirms that vaccinated people can still spread the Delta variant. It does have the more reassuring info that "35,000 vaccinated people a week in the United States are having symptomatic breakthrough infections out of a vaccinated population of more than 162 million", which comes out to 0.02%. I think that we'll be fine as long as we don't do stupid things like get drunk in bars with the mask off. In my neck of the woods, 84% of those eligible for the vaccine are vaccinated, with Asians being a whopping 95% vaccinated (!!). Cases have ticked up in the past few weeks, but deaths remain low. Spouse and I still wear masks in crowded areas and indoors, but we've started eating at restaurants outside when it's not super crowded. It's beginning to feel like that might just be the norm.

Writing:
I recently completed an event wherein I wrote 8 fics of ~5k each, totaling 42k words! It was a lot of writing for me, but as a result I feel like I've made some progress in the "learning to write" struggle.

I break learning a skill into 4 stages:
1) being able to recognize that something is wrong
2) being able to diagnose exactly what is wrong
3) being able to figure what needs to be done to fix it
4) having the skills to execute the fix
(huh, that's basically the 4 noble truths, isn't it?)

Anyway, steps 1-3 is basically Valley of Suck, where you can *see* that you can do better, but aren't *quite* able to do that. I feel like, half a year ago, I was at step 1, which is mostly being discontent because I know my writing lacked *something*. Since then, I've started getting better at recognizing what the problem is (whether it's at the pacing/story level or line-level). This past month, I think I've gotten to the point where I can say, "Oh, it's a pacing problem, and the fix is to move *this* emotional beat from the beginning of the fic to the end, and I need to tighten up the action here and divide up the fluff." And when I'm doing those sort of massive restructurings, I doing so with more confidence and less flailing. I'm also, extremely slowly, starting to get a sense of *how* to zoom in or zoom out with words, which is how I think about the line-level stuff. It's definitely helped me to think of the line level stuff like comic panels. "I want to do a close up on this guy's face here to show emotion" translates pretty well to "Oh, I should dwell on the emotionality of this moment here by adding a few more sentences and slowing the pace of the narrative a bit."

I've also been beta-ing for an author in Witcher fandom, which has been instructive in its own right -- being able to workshop the pacing of the story and discuss themes and pacing is lots of fun! And it's interesting to see how they think of it as "scene" vs "summary". I think what I do is I sketch out the bones of the thing first and then go through and identify the places where I need to "zoom in". Of course, this results in me leaving the kissing scenes for last, which meant that there was a day last week where I wrote 3 kissing scenes for 3 different fics. Writing about kissing is soooo weird. I can't not think about it as licking each others' tongues.

Anyways, my writing is far from *good*, especially on the line level, but I'm beginning to see the way out of the Valley of Suck. :) (Of course, once I get out, I'll be back to stage 1 again lol)

1 week comics class:
I taught a 1 week comics class to middle schoolers last week! It was ... surprisingly okay. It's always funny after a few weeks of struggling with writing, to come back to things that I'm good at. "Oh hey! I'm actually skilled at this thing called 'teaching'!" I can meet students where they are and then push them a bit further! I finally figured out a good way to teach middle schoolers to be aware of the margin and how their panels line up. (Apparently the magic words are "draw a big box on the page first, then draw lines to divide it into panels", because "margin" is not a helpful concept). I also managed to get them to brainstorm a collaborative story!

- I first created a template: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1TJtuRReI0HPUOHpcrvLpq_066SXgv4qfzX_8F5XbxC4/edit#slide=id.ge3124e4c45_0_190
- And then I let the kids pick one box and fill it out in a sort of chaotic burst of 12 kids typing on the same Google Slide. It was actually pretty cool because they could see what others were typing as they were typing, and so could adjust to fit: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1TJtuRReI0HPUOHpcrvLpq_066SXgv4qfzX_8F5XbxC4/edit#slide=id.ge3124e4c45_0_208
- From there I wrote it into a paragraph with the kids' feedback (there was a bit where we had to pause to vote on who the main character was -- the kitten, the sandwich, or the Astronaut).
- And then I listed out character and setting assets for the students to claim and design. While they were doing that, I roughed out what each page would be: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1TJtuRReI0HPUOHpcrvLpq_066SXgv4qfzX_8F5XbxC4/edit#slide=id.ge5eda0e308_19_14
- And then each kid dibsed a page and drew that page, using the character and asset designs as a guide. They posted wips on their own Google Slide so that they could see what the other kids were doing. It worked surprisingly well, despite the completely different art styles that each kid had.

Here's the final result for the 7th graders if you want to see:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/hw0kdkshx8cn89k/NS21-Kittens%20Adventure-single.pdf?dl=0
(also available in booklet form for anyone who wants to print it out)

Not bad for a few hours' work!

Miss Rutabaga and the End of Summer:
I restart work in less than 2 weeks! And then 2 weeks after that, Miss Rutabaga will be starting Kindergarten at the school that I work at. I thought I'd be more blasé about it, but starting kindergarten actually feels like a significant change from dropping her off at daycare every day. There's going to be new friends! A new campus! A new commute! I've bought her a new lunch bag and a new backpack, and I'm like, worried about the shuttle between campuses. (I teach at one campus and she'll be at the other campus. There's a shuttle that goes between the two that she'll be taking herself.) Just... I can't believe Miss Rutabaga is 5 now and will soon be navigating the elementary school campus as her own individual person. (She just lost her first baby tooth!)

I still have a bevy of work to do in the remaining time -- lay out my Wong Kim Ark comic, do some more sorting around the house, do lesson planning, plus camping with the fam and a work retreat with mom, but it's been a fruitful summer. :)
potofsoup: (Default)
Okay, I'm a little confused by the Tumblr Post Plus kerfuffle. Like, I understand that tumblr is disingenuously implying that fan content can be monetized, while at the same time ready to throw said fan creator to the wolves if the lawyers do come knocking. But ...

(a) Isn't that what most such services do? Does Patreon actually have terms of service that would protect the fan creator? I know when I got some fan work printed at a print shop, they had a similar "it's not our obligation to check fair use/licensing, so if lawyers come it's your problem not ours" sort of stipulation.

and

(b) Isn't it opt-in? Like, the Tumblr policy change around nsfw images and female presenting nipples was a mandatory removal/ban of content that applied to the entire site. Fan creators were losing blogs and losing content and audiences. Tumblr is not automatically putting all art behind a paywall here. Creators can choose to opt in. It's like Patreon, except that the content would show up on the audience's dashboard during their daily scroll, and allow you to format things as tumblr posts. Like, if I were to use Post Plus, I'd probably just make a separate sideblog and have that be subscription. I mean, I like Patreon just fine and don't intend to use Post Plus, but I'm also not quite understanding the degree of handwringing that seems to be going on, people talking about boycotts and dusting off their pillowfort accounts...

What aspect of this am I missing?
potofsoup: (Default)
Now that I've spent the day reading about it, I feel like the tragedy of Wong Kim Ark is that, even though he won birthright citizenship, the immigration laws at the time made it basically moot -- Wong Kim Ark was one of very few Chinese Americans to be born in America, and he himself went back to China to find a wife, since Chinese women were basically not allowed to immigrate. He had 3 sons over 5 trips to China, and only got to see them once every 5 years or so. The Supreme Court decision was very much about guaranteeing that Irish and German immigrants were able to retain birthright citizenship. So... yeah. I'm not saying it didn't have a lasting effect, but it had a very limited effect on Wong Kim Ark's own ability to have children born in the US.
potofsoup: (Default)
OMG I love doing research for comics it's sooooo much fun.

I'm looking at Wong Kim Ark stuff and then I found this great website on Look Tin Eli (he's known as Look Tin Sing in the case precedent that was cited in the Wong Kim Ark case) and since Wong Kim Ark got his funding for the court case from the Six Companies in 1894, and Look Tin Eli was a big part of the Six Companies by 1907.... maybe they met each other? OMG what if Look Tin Eli was like "we gotta fund this court case"

30 min ago I had no idea who this guy was and now I'm like *_* broooomance.... (except that Look is obviously much wealthier than Wong -- all the case files are like "Wong is a *laborer*", whereas Look starts a bank)

God, the 1880s and 1890s were such an active time for Chinese cases (for obvious reasons) but I love it so much and I want to know EVERYTHING.

Here's a few documented by the National Archives: http://recordsofrights.org/search?tag=Chinese+Americans

----
unfortunately now I need to figure out how to tell the Wong Kim Ark story in a small number of pages
potofsoup: (Default)
Watched some "retro" anime stuff last night and WOW the way the opening song to Weiss Kreuz whips me back to high school, sitting on the grass with my group of friends talking about the hot gay assassins and staying up late to read horribad fanfiction. KareKano opening brings me back to first time attending anime club in college. The opening to Last Exile takes me to that year of living with gf and deciding that I shouldn't cosplay blonde characters.

It's also so weird to me that back then, given my parents' restrictions on media consumption at home and my financial inability to buy VHS tapes and mail them to other fans that I found on Geocities, my consumption of anime was primarily through reading extremely detailed episode summaries and fan fiction, back when it was like, one person's website with whatever fanfics and character bios and wallpapers they felt like putting up. I think I watched <3 episodes of Fushigi Yuugi, Kenshin, Weiss Kreuz, Gundam Wing, but I sure as heck can still name all of the characters based on a still image ensemble shot.

Anyway, here's a nice retrospective:



(I fell into this youtube hole from "guess the anime opening" videos, of which this one is not bad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wyQpSDls5E . I of course failed all the ones labeled "super easy" because I have not watched anime for a while.)


((and then somehow listening to old anime openings lead spouse into a conversation about optimism vs. naivete, cynicism vs. being realistic, and how he thinks we need to sell the house and move to either Canada or New Zealand by 2024 because California will burn and America is a failed state. SIGH))
potofsoup: (Default)
Today I wrapped up GM-ing a Primetime Adventures (PTA) story that's a sort of steampunk/magic thing set during the Russo-Japanese war! :D

The larger context was that I've been wanting to do table-top roleplaying, but it's hard to do it with Spouse because then we'd have to find a time where both of us are free, which translates to "10pm after the child is asleep," which is... a difficult time. So back in March, I said to Spouse, "Hey, maybe we should roleplay with other people," so he joined a DnD campaign, and I asked my coworkers whether anyone was interested in doing a PTA game with me. I specified that I was fine with history, fantasy, steampunk or space operas, as long as it's not Euro-centric, and got 3 players. Us being history nerds, we decided it was going to be Russo-Japanese war steampunk. It ended up being a story about a mercenary transport ship who had to navigate through nationalist sentiment and weird religious syncretism stuff in order to deliver (or not deliver) a special cargo. So it's like... Firefly, but with 1910s submarine technology and a dose of folk religion. (Our ship's name was the Kappa and it literally had a kappa powering the engine.)

Anyway, I'm not here to talk about the story (although it turned out to be a fun one -- I'll put the summary at the end). I'm here to talk about running a PTA game to a bunch of people whose only TTRPG experience has been DnD.

Setting Up )

PTA House rules )

Some more GM thoughts )

The story itself )
potofsoup: (Default)
random thoughts, not organized )

Now I just have to insert Steve back into these things so that I can once again ship Samstevebucky properly :)

FATWS ep 5

Apr. 16th, 2021 10:49 am
potofsoup: (Default)
okay fine I finally shelled out money for a month of Disney Plus, since my school's Marvel club isn't meeting today.

spoilers )
potofsoup: (Default)
I was kinda meh about ep 3 and so didn't update, but anyway:

spoilers for FATWS ep 3 and 4 )

urg writing

Apr. 4th, 2021 10:08 pm
potofsoup: (Default)
urg writing is hard.

Or rather, when I'm drawing, I know how to diagnose problems and fix it. (Things like "oh, the torso is too big relative to the head, let's make the head bigger" "the positioning is too boring, let's change the framing" "in order for this shot to work, I'll need to be able to draw legs and today is not a good leg day so let's switch it up") 80% of the problems I diagnose, I'm able to fix. The other 20% requires leveling up my art skill so... it's gonna take more time. (Although it's happening, slowly but surely -- when I look back at stuff I drew 5 years ago, I'm like "oh, I can actually draw this better now, so that's pretty heartening.)

But diagnosing problems and fixing it are skills that I'm still trying to build up re: writing.

I think my recent spate of finishing wips has helped on the problem diagnosing front. I've done things like:
- oh, when this Bucky makes this decision, it leads to plot that I don't feel equipped to write, so let's have Bucky make a different decision
- these scenes, while amusing, are actually irrelevant to the bulk of the story and drags out the beginning. Let me just condense this into a a 200 word montage and move into the story faster
- it's boring for Sam to have missed all of the fight and come home to an argument, so let's move the argument *to* the fight

Much of it involves moving story chunks around, deleting scenes that just don't work, and starting or stopping at a different place. These story level things are easier for me to diagnose, I think, because they're very adjacent to comicking. And it's so much easier to move things around in text than with panels! Every time I drag some words to a different place I'm just like "!!!! I can just .... do that????"

I think what's much harder for me to diagnose, much less fix, is when the scene needs more different words in order to convey a certain feeling or to adjust the pacing. (See, I don't even have to words to describe this). So much of this type of problem involves me going "urg, I need more words here" and then saying "I don't wanna". In comicking terms, it's like I don't want to draw the background to a splash panel, even if I know I gotta to make the scene work. The problem is that I know I can hunker down and get the background drawn, I *don't* know whether I can actually do the fancy words, and I'm not sure if it's even the right place to do the word stuff. (And then I read something that I wrote 5 years ago and I'm like "dang that's not bad", whereas whatever I *just* wrote feels objectively worse.)

Anyways, (a) urg, writing, and (b) guess I should keep working at it

FATWS

Mar. 19th, 2021 11:15 pm
potofsoup: (Default)
Watched FATWS today with my school's Marvel club, which meant that I didn't need to shell out for D+. But I enjoyed it enough and might want to rewatch bits of it for fandom purposes that I might shell out for D+ after all.

spoilers )
potofsoup: (Default)
I'm pretty happy with myself -- it feels like I've cleared out a lot of pent up feelings about Endgame / pent up comicking desires!

It started with someone adding a comment to Cadillac asking where part 5 was (tumblr-bot had thought the sand was nsfw), which then lead me to say, "hey, let me see if I can just finish this real quick." And I did! What helped was just saying "hey, past-self put too many arbitrary restrictions on this. Let me just ignore all those dumb things." (Arbitrary restrictions like that it had to be all close-ups. Dear self of 2017 -- that's just called Bad Comicking.) That took 2 evenings.

And then, since I'd finished a 4-year-old project, I decided to finish a 2-year-old one, which was the Thor part of my Endgame fixits. For this one, the blockage was that I needed to look up reference video, but didn't want to buy Endgame. Thankfully I found the necessary clip on youtube. Huzzah! (That was mostly Tuesday.)

And then, I realized that Bucky's birthday (Mar 10) was coming up, and for once I remembered more than 1 day in advance. So I re-read my previous ones, and drew the comic over ... ~5 days? Maybe a bit longer -- the comic was slippery, and unlike the previous 2, there wasn't a thing that's been sitting in my head for a few years, just waiting for execution. First I'd wanted to do some fluffy reminiscing, but then I realized that it's too early for that. Then I wanted to do something about Steve watching over Bucky's family in the past, but then I realized it wasn't logistically practical. Then I got upset over the fact that Steve lived 70 years without Bucky, and realized that I still have residual annoyance at Steve to deal with. And then I had to figure out a way to address that with the right tone and keep things hopeful. So... that took a while, but I got it done by Wed night!

And then yesterday afternoon, I drafted Vormir after the idea settled in my head as I wrote responses to some AO3 commenters, and somehow between last night and this afternoon, I as able to draw it a post it! :D!!

So yeah, it's been a lot of comicking -- the adrenaline rush is pretty great, ngl. :D
potofsoup: (Default)
Hey hey, it is a New Year if you follow a specific lunisolar calendar!

I made wontons and spring rolls last night, and fried mochi year cakes this morning. Maybe I'll make a little "how-to" for dumplings some time, but, in the meantime, here are my highlights from the New Year's Gala, aka the annual variety show extravaganza that every Chinese person is supposed to watch (and then complain about), the way every American is supposed to watch the Thanksgiving Parade, or maybe the Superbowl. It's got skits, songs, dances, magic, etc. More importantly for me, it's a really interesting window into what China (the government) feels like China (the people) would like to celebrate. All conveniently packaged on youtube for the overseas Chinese (even though youtube is blocked in China, good job)

Anyway, here's the full playlist if you're interested, but I'm going to post some good stuff and some "oh no, China" moments:

Favorite song: I still remember being 8 and listening to 张也 on a cassette tape, so it was really cool to see that she's still singing! The duet with 周深 really showed off his range, too. The song's conceit about lighting lanterns and making well wishes is very sweet, too, even if it's also tied to the China Dream.


On the other hand, I feel like this song really captures the kitschiness of the Gala: the entire song revolves around a pun (the word for cow is the the same as the word for "twist", so the song is "Let's do the twist"). It also features dancing cow robots, a robot that writes calligraphy, and far too much digital shenanigans:


I really like this song, 可可托海的牧羊人, it's refreshingly simple after all the digital extravagance. That said, it is also appalling given what's happening in Xinjiang. I wish I would divorce it from that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OfsT5jWHXag

Jay Chou's "Mojito" started pretty good, but it quickly got a little surreal and over-produced:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUWiDCCJDGc

Given that they have to do 我爱你中国 every year ("I love you, China", it's like America the Beautiful), I was impressed that they went with the classy route of simple piano this year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esa_ZvE4keg

On the other hand, here is the most appalling song/dance, called "Festivities": it, um... has Egypt for some reason? And a whole host of other racist caricatures?? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2wgTh4O-LM . NO CHINA NO

Also, there is a required song about the military every year, and another about how China's 56 ethnicities totally live in harmony. It's actually pretty interesting to see what they choose. The military one is about defending one's borders: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8e_TYx6g5w , and worth watching to see how China portrays its military. I can't help wonder how long it took the soldiers to write "long live China" in the snow for that one particular shot.

On the other hand, the ethnicity song is ... is literally the old party song from the 50s and 60s, featuring lyrics like “mother merely birthed my body, but it is the Party that lights my heart”:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GyL1uhVXiM
It's chilling, actually, to see how big the difference is from a decade ago, when the major ethnicities were able to do their own song segment.


And if you understand Chinese, here's some skits that I liked:

如此家长 is about the stress of parenting and signing your kid up for too many classes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YNOQnGmT0mo

阳台 doesn't have its own clip, but is a skit about Wuhan under lockdown: https://youtu.be/Ac9ADx8CEhA?t=98

开往春天的幸福 just made me laugh a lot, romance of the working people: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzNsYgr_rK0
potofsoup: (Default)
So, I got into Western fiction pretty late, and I still remember reading Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy in high school and hitting the end of the book and saying "wait, the story is just beginning!" (Yes -- I completely missed the humor of the book completely). Then I read The Golden Compass and was like, "wait, this book ended on a cliffhanger???" And, like ... I know I'm supposed to read the next one, but guess what? I never did, because I was so pissed that I went through ALL that effort, only to read the beginning of a story. I felt so betrayed by the fact that the book didn't have a complete story arc. This isn't to say I don't like multi-book series -- I'm fine if I know ahead of time how many volumes it takes to have the complete story told (such as LotR), or if the books in the series, while featuring the same universe and the same people, are telling discrete stories.

But it's incredibly frustrating to me when I'm offered a unit of a thing that I expect to tell me a story with a beginning, middle and end, AND IT DOESN'T. I think this is what I find frustrating with what Spouse calls "Netflix pacing", which is the recent trend for 10-13-episode seasons that you're supposed to binge-watch. It usually takes 3 episodes to set up the characters, another 5 for the core plot, and then a final 3-5 for whatever climax/denouement. In these cases, the unit of the thing is not an "episode", but rather, a "season." But it's still pretending that the unit is "episode." If someone said to me, "hey, do you want to watch 1/10th of a movie tonight?" I'd be like, "No." But if someone said to me, "hey, wanna watch an episode of something tonight?" I'd be like "Sure." And it used to be that while episodes would have some time devoted to the season-long arc, it would still be standalone -- DS9 was like that, A:TLA was like that. But now more and more shows seem to forget to have a story for the episode.

TV shows used to be 99% episode plot, because you couldn't count on people watching for a whole season, and even now, procedurals and comedy shows tend to be that way. And then there were the TV shows that were 90% episode plot and 10% season plot, which was usually facilitated by the "Previously on..." segments at the beginning of an episode. With maybe a 2-episode season opener and season finale that have a bit more cohesion. But when's the last time a new show had a "Previously on..."? I feel like so many new shows are 99% season plot, which means watching an episode just leaves me feeling dissatisfied. Half the episodes are spent setting up things in the future, and the other half of the episodes are spent wrapping up, which means there's actually very little of each episode that actually tells a story.

Again, I'm trying to figure out what specifically I find frustrating about this, because I happily watched 26 episodes of Escaflowne, which is also a story that is told in a season length and not an episode length. Maybe it's, once again, the fact that I knew the commitment going in. But it might also be that Escaflowne was still expected to have some *story* happen in each episode, and not just some *setup*. Episode 1 introduced Hitomi, her relationships and friendships, and ended with her in a different world and already embroiled in the plot of Van and the guymelefs. All in <30 minutes. In comparison, we just watched the first episode of the Expanse, which introduced to us one (1) mystery girl, one (1) gritty detective, one (1) Indian lady who apparently is okay with torture, and one (1) freight ship guy who is trying to avoid having responsibilities. It ends with an explosion that may???? be plot????? but is mostly just mysterious???????? So after an hour of watching, I now know a tiny bit about 4 characters, have very little sense of the season-long plot, and I guess I'm supposed to ... keep watching? Let the 5 second countdown happen and binge for another 2-3 hours? Like, nothing against the Expanse -- apparently everyone likes it, and there's some good political intrigue in it. But I can't help imagining if the episode pacing would have been different if binge-watching is not the default. For example, what about starting with the freighter guy getting a distress call, and introduce the other characters as they become relevant to the core story?

I was talking to Spouse the other day about how Star Wars: A New Hope was one of the few Star Wars where you didn't have to read the opening scroll, where you can just jump into the movie and be as clueless as Luke and it wrapped up at the end and everyone got awards. In contrast, the first Star Wars movie I ever watched was Return of the Jedi, and oh boy that movie makes no sense if you haven't watched the other two -- I didn't know who the main character was for the first 10 minutes, I didn't know why there was a guy who was frozen in a slab of wall, I didn't know why only Luke had telekinesis powers. I was so confused when Darth Vader picked up the Emperor because I was like "um okay why didn't you do that in any time in the last 30 years?"

And as more and more movies are part of "cinematic universes" (I blame MCU for making it the "safe bet" in Hollywood), I feel like more and more movies are also falling into the trap of "Netflix pacing", except on a movie scale. Now, it's not about watching a 45 minute episode at home and feeling vaguely dissatisfied because 90% of the episode was building up to something else, but rather watching a whole 3 hour long movie and feeling a similar sense of dissatisfaction. What is the standalone story of Endgame, really? At least with Infinity War, the standalone part is Thanos' Fetchquest / Earth finally getting people together to defend against a world-ending threat, and the theme of "we do not trade lives" is threaded throughout. Endgame's standalone part is ... the Time Heist? or Tony having a heart? And if the theme is "misplaced nostalgia for the past", I guess they hit it, but if the theme is "what are you willing to sacrifice" then um give Nat's sacrifice proper weight, and give Steve a proper sacrifice. And if it's an ongoing cinematic universe, then each movie is just setting up for the next one or wrapping up the previous one, and there's an infinite number of next ones, which leaves very little space to actually ... tell a story. Or have sensible character arcs. (Tony's character arc was great in IM 1-3, but then he had to regress in order to fit the Avengers storytelling. Steve's character arc was short-shrifted by only having 2 movies and being too afraid of teh gays between Steve and Bucky)

Anyway, it's not that these "Netflix pacing" stories aren't effectively told in a 10 hour season or a 10 movie extended universe, but I'm one of those people who'd like to spend 30-45 minutes watching a show and feel like I got a nice tidbit of story out of it, and there are fewer and fewer of these types of shows out there. I feel like we're losing the ability to tell concise, effective stories in this show/film medium, which I'd like to mark and lament.

Profile

potofsoup: (Default)
potofsoup

About

#me
#mine
AO3
Patreon
Storenvy
potofsoupyfeels at gmail

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 9th, 2025 03:16 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios